Opt-out directory
How to stop mail from The Wisconsin Cheeseman
Opt-out contact information
Contact The Wisconsin Cheeseman directly using any option below. These are The Wisconsin Cheeseman's own opt-out channels.
Allow 8–12 weeks
Print runs are scheduled in advance. Mail already printed may still arrive after you opt out.
Your options
Both paths work. Pick what fits your situation.
Contact The Wisconsin Cheeseman yourself
- Cost
- Free
- Best for
- One mailer, one time
- Effort
- visit their site, Call, or email
- Timeline
- 8–12 weeks typical
Let PaperKarma send it
- Cost
- Use 1 of 4 FREE opt-outs.
- Best for
- ALL junk mail in your mailbox now
- Effort
- Enter your info once. Reuse easily.
- Timeline
- Same as DIY; we handle follow-up
Subscription details at Pricing
Current opt-out methods for The Wisconsin Cheeseman mail
-
Email request
— Use the Email option on this page to ask Wisconsin Cheeseman to stop catalogs and promotional mail. Include your name and mailing address as they appear on the mailer.
If sending your opt-out request by email, use this helpful template for The Wisconsin Cheeseman:
Hello, I'm writing to request that The Wisconsin Cheeseman permanently remove my address from all direct mail lists, including your internal house list and any rented or third-party lists used to source your mailings. The name and address to remove as they appear on a recently delivered unwanted mailer: [NAME] [ADDRESS] [CITY ST ZIP] A few notes for your direct mail team: • I have never subscribed to marketing communications from The Wisconsin Cheeseman. • Since I haven't opted in with you directly, the source is most likely a rented or co-op list. Please also flag this address with your list partners so it's suppressed at the source. Please confirm in writing once the suppression is complete. I've attached an image of the mailer for reference. Thank you, [NAME]
Replace the bracketed fields ([NAME], [ADDRESS], [CITY ST ZIP]) before sending. Attach a photo of the mailer if you have one, and keep the reply for your records.
-
PaperKarma app
— Photograph the mailer in the PaperKarma app. Once you opt out of this sender, you can opt out of 100,000+ other mailers in the same app.
-
Phone
— Call +1-800-693-0834. Customer service is available Mon–Fri 8am–12am Central. Request removal from catalog and marketing lists. A phone request can take 5 to 10 minutes or longer, depending on the phone tree, hold time, and whether they offer a callback.
What to Expect After Opting Out
Allow 8 to 12 weeks for list updates. Order confirmations, shipment notices, and gift messages for purchases you place will still arrive. Food-gift retailers often mail heavily before holidays; one more catalog after your request is normal.
Why Do You Receive The Wisconsin Cheeseman Mail?
Wisconsin Cheeseman has sold cheese, meats, bakery, and assorted food gifts by catalog and online since 1946, positioning itself as a Midwestern gift brand for holidays and corporate thank-yous.
You get catalogs when you ordered in the past, received a gift shipped from their warehouse, or matched a cooperative list used for cheese-and-snack prospecting. The mail feels nostalgic on purpose: savory towers and sausage assortments photographed for people who would rather ship food than wrap it themselves.
How to Prevent General Junk Mail Proactively
DMAchoice — Mail preference service for many national marketers.
NOTE: DMAchoice will not stop mail from The Wisconsin Cheeseman as it is not an active member of the ANA.
OptOutPrescreen — Prescreened credit and insurance opt-out.
NOTE: OptOutPrescreen will not opt you out of The Wisconsin Cheeseman mail. It only covers prescreened credit card and insurance offers.
PaperKarma — Photograph mailers and opt out from your phone.
Your Data Privacy Rights (CCPA & Beyond)
Review Wisconsin Cheeseman’s privacy information linked from their website for state privacy rights. For catalog opt-out, use the Email option on this page or call +1-800-693-0834.
Frequently asked questions
How long until the mail stops?
Plan on **8 to 12 weeks**.
How do I stop mail for a previous resident?
Opt out with the name on the catalog and note they no longer live at your address.
Will the mail stop if I move?
Send a fresh opt-out with your new address when catalogs follow you.
Stop junk mail from The Wisconsin Cheeseman and everyone else.
Download the PaperKarma app free. Snap photos of unwanted mail: The Wisconsin Cheeseman, catalogs, credit offers, charities, and more. We contact senders for you.